九一星空无限

ZB ZB
Opinion
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Up next
ZB

John MacDonald: Isn't enrolling on election day better than not voting at all?

Author
John MacDonald ,
Publish Date
Fri, 25 Jul 2025, 1:04pm
Photo / Alex Cairns
Photo / Alex Cairns

John MacDonald: Isn't enrolling on election day better than not voting at all?

Author
John MacDonald ,
Publish Date
Fri, 25 Jul 2025, 1:04pm

Election Day is like Christmas Day, with some of us not getting ourselves organised until the very last minute - even though we鈥檝e known for ages that it鈥檚 happening.  

Christmas day is never sprung on us. We know it happens every 12 months, but there鈥檚 a lot of last-minute panicking, isn鈥檛 there?  

We get even more warning with Election Day. We know it happens every three years, but there's the same last-minute rush.  

Especially for the 110,000 people who were in the last-minute camp at the last election, enrolling to vote on the same day they voted.  

But the Government鈥檚 not having any more of that and, as part of its changes to the way elections are run, it鈥檚 doing away with same-day enrolment. Which I think is a mistake.  

But ACT MP Todd Stephenson is loving it, saying: 鈥淚t鈥檚 outrageous that someone completely disengaged and lazy can rock up to the voting booth, get registered there and then, and then vote to tax other people's money away.鈥  

But he鈥檚 missing the point completely, because isn鈥檛 it brilliant that more than 100,000 people got to vote in the last election because they could enrol on the day?  

Isn鈥檛 it the ones who didn鈥檛 vote at all who are the lazy ones?  

The Government鈥檚 missing the point too. Because instead of penalising voters because it鈥檚 system can鈥檛 cope with last minute enrolments, it should be coming up with a system that can cope.  

It should be building a system that enables same day enrolment instead of getting rid of it.  

What it鈥檚 doing is effectively reversing something that was brought in for the 2020 election by the previous government. But it's going even further than just reversing what Labour did, and people are going to have to be enrolled and have their details up to date before the 12 days of advance voting begins.  

The Government says it鈥檚 making the changes so the votes can be counted quicker. So that we get a result quicker, and so the politicians can get on with doing coalition deals.   

But that鈥檚 just an excuse for not putting in the effort to come up with a better system to count the votes. And I鈥檓 not the only one saying that today either.  

Electoral law expert Graeme Edgeler is pouring cold water on it as well, saying there鈥檚 nothing stopping the politicians who look like they've been elected from beginning coalition negotiations before the final special votes are counted.  

He says the final results can change by one or two seats, but nothing dramatic, and he says, 鈥渢he time delay just doesn't seem like a particularly good reason for this."  

As for one of the other changes it鈥檚 making 鈥攄elivering on its promise to bring-in a total ban on prisoners voting鈥 that gets a thumbs down from me too.  

Again, it鈥檚 getting rid of something brought in by the previous government: voting rights for prisoners serving sentences of less than three years. Which is a mistake because I see a prisoner being able to vote as a way of keeping them engaged with the outside world.  

You might recall a few months back, Sir Ron Young was finishing up as head of the Parole Board and he was saying that the reoffending rate for prisoners who serve short prison terms of two to three years is higher than those inside for longer.   

That鈥檚 because they have way less opportunities to get themselves rehabilitated and they end up spending a lot of their time behind bars hanging out with serious crims.  

So he was advocating for keeping these prisoners more engaged with the outside world, and I see voting rights as a way of doing that.  

What鈥檚 more, how does a prisoner serving two years being allowed to vote affect you? Answer: it doesn鈥檛. It has no impact on you and no impact on me. 

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you