the podcast on

Do you think the Government and councils would be 鈥渕orally bankrupt鈥 if they stopped paying people out when their properties are so flood-damaged that they can鈥檛 live there anymore?
And would you feel the same about people living in areas at risk of flooding being forced to pay more for flood schemes and sea walls because they鈥檙e the ones who benefit most?
That鈥檚 what a panel of experts is recommending to the Government. But a climate policy expert is saying that would be, you guessed it, 鈥渕orally bankrupt鈥. And I agree.
What鈥檚 more, I think this approach would let councils off the hook for allowing places to be built in crazy, at-risk locations.
What鈥檚 happened, is an independent reference group set up by the Ministry for the Environment has come up with a list of recommendations to help the Government work on some climate adaptation legislation.
Adaptation being what you do when something like climate change and sea-level rise threatens to take-out an area.
This group is made up of economists, people from the banking and insurance sectors, local government and iwi. So a wide range of people. And if I there鈥檚 an overarching theme to their advice, it would be this: 鈥淵ou鈥檙e on your own buddy.鈥
And instead of looking to the councils and governments for hand-outs and direction, people should have to decide for themselves if they鈥檙e going to stay living where they are.
And if their properties get flooded and there鈥檚 no way they can keep on living there, then they shouldn't expect their local council or Wellington to buy them out.
Talk about hardcore. Talk about morally bankrupt.
This group of experts isn鈥檛 stopping there, either. It鈥檚 also saying that, if you live in an area where there is a risk of flooding and things like sea walls and flood schemes are needed, then you and your neighbours should pay more for those things because you鈥檙e the ones who benefit the most.
So, if we apply that to some of the things that have happened here in Canterbury, that would mean people in the Flockton Basin area in Christchurch, paying more for the privilege of living somewhere that used to flood at the drop of a hat.
Remember that? And how the council poured truckloads of money into a pumping system that stopped the water overflowing in the Dudley Creek area and flooding the streets and houses?
The Christchurch City Council spent $49 million on a flood mitigation scheme in Flockton Basin. Elsewhere in town, it spent about $70 million to deal with flooding issues along the Heathcote River. That included buying-out people's houses. Some friends of mine had their place bought out as part of that scheme.
But under these recommendations to the Government, the people in Flockton Basin would be expected to pay more than the rest of us because they鈥檙e the ones who are benefiting directly from their streets and houses not flooding anymore.
Also under these recommendations, my mates wouldn鈥檛 have their house bought out by the council 鈥 even though they can鈥檛 live there anymore because it keeps flooding
I would hate to see us take this approach. Which is why agree with climate policy expert, Emeritus Professor Jonathan Boston from Victoria University, who is saying today that leaving people high and not necessarily dry like this would be 鈥渕orally bankrupt鈥.
He says: "One of the core responsibilities of any government is to protect its citizens and to deal with natural disasters and so on. That is above almost anything else."
He鈥檚 also criticising this group鈥檚 recommendation that any changes be phased-in within the next 20 years, saying that the risks and impacts of climate change are going to continue evolving beyond this 20-year deadline.
He says to put an end-date on it is "Morally bankrupt and highly undesirable".
And, as I say, it would let councils off-the-hook. Because for me, if a council gives consent for something to built somewhere, then that same council needs to carry the can if it turns out that that something is somewhere it shouldn鈥檛 be.
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you
Get the iHeart App
Get more of the radio, music and podcasts you love with the FREE iHeartRadio app. Scan the QR code to download now.
Download from the app stores
Stream unlimited music, thousands of radio stations and podcasts all in one app. iHeartRadio is easy to use and all FREE