九一星空无限

ZB ZB
Opinion
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Up next
ZB

What happened to MH370? Disturbing theories, twists, latest search 10 years on

Author
Heath Moore,
Publish Date
Fri, 8 Mar 2024, 10:17am
It has been 10 years since Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 disappeared without a trace. One theory is that Pilot Zaharie Ahmad Shah crashed the plane in a murder-suicide plot.
It has been 10 years since Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 disappeared without a trace. One theory is that Pilot Zaharie Ahmad Shah crashed the plane in a murder-suicide plot.

What happened to MH370? Disturbing theories, twists, latest search 10 years on

Author
Heath Moore,
Publish Date
Fri, 8 Mar 2024, 10:17am

On March 8, 2014, Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 carrying 239 people on board was supposed to be flying from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing.

It was a route that had been flown thousands of times over the years. For the passengers on board and ground staff at the airport, it appeared to be a normal day.

The flight had taken off and was on track for Beijing. Then suddenly the Boeing 777 disappeared from the radar without issuing any distress calls.

Subsequent evidence suggests MH370 continued flying for another seven hours.

There is no plane, little wreckage, and听no answers for the families听of the 239 people on board.

A decade on, it has become one of aviation鈥檚听biggest mysteries.

So听what actually happened to MH370?听Where did it disappear to, how did it disappear, and why did it disappear?

We take a look at what we know, the working theories behind its disappearance, and how close authorities are to solving one of the world鈥檚 baffling mysteries.

Malaysia Airlines flight MH370 vanished 10 years ago with 239 people on board, including New Zealander Paul Weeks. Photo / FileMalaysia Airlines flight MH370 vanished 10 years ago with 239 people on board, including New Zealander Paul Weeks. Photo / File

What we know about MH370: Timeline

The flight and disappearance

The aircraft took off at 12.42am on 8 March, and was being flown by Captain Zaharie Ahmad Shah from Kuala Lumpur to Beijing.

The flight was going as planned, and at 1.19am, just 37 minutes into the flight, the captain acknowledged an instruction from Malaysian air-traffic controllers to transition to Vietnamese airspace, saying: 鈥淕oodnight, Malaysian three-seven-zero.鈥

Those were the last words heard from the aircraft.

A minute later, controllers in Kuala Lumpur noticed the plane passing a waypoint, 鈥淚gari鈥, about a third of the way from the Malaysian coast to Vietnam. Within seconds, MH370 had disappeared from radar screens.

鈥淗e did not read back the assigned frequency, which was inconsistent with radio-telephony procedures,鈥 notes the official investigation report.

Malaysian military radar continued to track the plane, which 鈥渁lmost immediately鈥 turned to the left until it was travelling south-west, the opposite direction from its destination in Beijing.

One hour and 10 minutes into the flight, First Officer Fariq Abdul Hamid鈥檚 cellphone registered with a cell tower below, though no other data was transmitted. Flight 370 then turned towards northwest along the Strait of Malacca.

Route map of MH370.Route map of MH370.

Transmissions of data pinged to satellites intermittently until 8.19am, a whole seven hours after the last verbal interaction between the pilot and the control centre.

Those pings picked up were two hours after it was scheduled to land in Beijing.

The aircraft was officially logged as missing.

What authorities do know after weeks of analysis following the disappearance is that radar tracking showed the jet had changed course to fly west over the South East Asia peninsula before suddenly turning south over the Indian Ocean.

The official search for MH370

In the hours and days after its disappearance, an official search for MH370 was undertaken.

The official search area for MH370 was 190km radius from its last known position, south ofTh峄 Chu Island, Thailand, north of Malaysia and south east of Vietnam in the South China Sea.

The area being examined then extended to the Strait of Malacca along the west coast of the Malay Peninsula, with waters both to the east of Malaysia in the Gulf of Thailand, and in the Strait of Malacca along Malaysia鈥檚 west coast, being searched.

Satellite images released by the Australian Maritime Safety Authority on March 20, 2014 show what could be debris from missing MH370. Satellite images released by the Australian Maritime Safety Authority on March 20, 2014 show what could be debris from missing MH370.

Numerous sightings of possible debris were made, but no debris from Flight 370 was discovered.

Offshore oil slicks near Vietnam also tested negative for aviation fuel.

In mid-March 2014, Malaysian officials announced that an unidentified aircraft, possibly Flight 370, was last located by military radar at 2.15 in the Andaman Sea, 320km northwest of Penang Island and near the limits of the military radar鈥檚 coverage.

Nothing was ever found to be linked to MH370.

Efforts then shifted to the southern Indian Ocean, west of Australia, where they searched thousands of kilometres of ocean.

They conducted surface, underwater locator beacon, and seafloor sonar survey searches. Nothing of relevance was found until debris washed ashore on Africa and tiny islands in the Indian Ocean in 2015.

Experts have determined this wing fragment is from missing MH370.
Experts have determined this wing fragment is from missing MH370.

Fragments of MH370 wreckage found

The first definitive fragments of MH370 wreckage were discovered in July 2015 by searchers scouring the Indian Ocean.

Searchers confirmed three pieces as certainly from the plane, which included the wing flap found in Tanzania in June 2015, a plane wing fragment found in Mauritius, and the flaperon found on Reunion Island.

Other pieces of fragments were also discovered between 2015 and 2016听that were deemed highly likely to have come from MH370.

These included a cabin interior panel in Madagascar, an engine cowling in South Africa, a main cabin interior panel in Mauritius, and a horizontal stabaliser and flap track fairing on beaches in Mozambique.

Debris believed to be from the missing flight MH370 on display during a remembrance event marking the 10th anniversary of its disappearance at the Empire Subang in Subang Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia on March 3, 2024. Photo / Nazri Mohamad, EPADebris believed to be from the missing flight MH370 on display during a remembrance event marking the 10th anniversary of its disappearance at the Empire Subang in Subang Jaya, Selangor, Malaysia on March 3, 2024. Photo / Nazri Mohamad, EPA

While some parts were confirmed to be from flight MH370, the plane鈥檚 wreckage has yet to be found.

Attention has since turned to why and how it disappeared.

Kiwi father Paul Weeks missing on MH370: Widow speaks out

One of the passengers on board the fateful flight was 37-year-old Kiwi father of two, Paul Weeks.

He was travelling to Mongolia to start a new job as a mechanical engineer when the plane went missing.

His wife Danica was left to raise the couple鈥檚 sons Lincoln, 3 at the time, and Jackson, 1.

Former Christchurch man Paul Weeks, who was on Malaysian Airlines flight MH370. Photo / Supplied, FileFormer Christchurch man Paul Weeks, who was on Malaysian Airlines flight MH370. Photo / Supplied, File

He was one of two Kiwis on the flight -- the other was Ximin Wang, 50, from Auckland.

Eight years after MH370 disappeared, Weeks鈥 wife Danica spoke out claiming she believed the incident was murder and not a mechanical fault, which was one of the working theories at the time.

Danica, who has now remarried, said the turning point was analysis from British aerospace engineer Richard Godfrey published late last year.

鈥淚 was so staunch about saying it wasn鈥檛 the pilot,鈥 she told Sky 九一星空无限.

Danica lost her first husband Paul Weeks when Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 disappeared on 8 March 2014. Photo / SuppliedDanica lost her first husband Paul Weeks when Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 disappeared on 8 March 2014. Photo / Supplied

鈥淏ut now I have to throw all of that out after nearly eight years (since the disappearance) and three years of searching (for the plane, by the authorities).

鈥淚 never believed it was the pilot. Unfortunately, Richard Godfrey has said that he believes with this point that the pilot was in control. And look, it makes sense that we鈥檝e searched for a ghost plane, haven鈥檛 found it. So maybe we have to step forward and 鈥 search on that basis now.鈥

Theories on what happened to MH370

Experts were 鈥渦nable to determine the real cause for the disappearance鈥, according to a final commission report and the crash location was never confirmed, although parts have washed ashore, mainly on Madagascar.

Since the disappearance, a number of theories have been detailed by authorities and aviation experts, including hijacking, murder-suicide and uncontrolled decompression.

The shadow of a Royal New Zealand Air Force P3 Orion is seen on low-level cloud while the aircraft searches for missing Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 in the southern Indian Ocean. Photo / AP
The shadow of a Royal New Zealand Air Force P3 Orion is seen on low-level cloud while the aircraft searches for missing Malaysia Airlines Flight MH370 in the southern Indian Ocean. Photo / AP

Theory on how it crashed: MH370 slammed into the Indian Ocean

The piece of debris discovered by a Madagascan fisherman suggests whoever was flying the plane purposely tried to destroy the aircraft and sink it with all the passengers on board.

A听report published by British engineer Richard Godfrey听and self-described American MH370 wreckage hunter Blaine Gibson suggests the washed-up landing gear door was probably penetrated from the inside by the plane鈥檚 engines disintegrating on impact.

It makes it highly likely the landing gear was down when the aircraft crashed into the Indian Ocean.

Godfrey and Gibson suggested the airliner crashed quickly and deliberately.

鈥淭he fact that the damage was from the interior side to the exterior side ... leads to the conclusion that the landing gear was highly extended on impact, which in turn supports the conclusion that there was an active pilot until the end of the flight,鈥 the report reads.

It added: 鈥淭he level of damage with fractures on all sides and the extreme force of the penetration right through the debris item leads to the conclusion that the end of the flight was in a high-speed dive designed to ensure the aircraft broke up into as many pieces as possible.

鈥淭he crash of MH370 was anything but a soft landing on the ocean.鈥

They determined the combination of the high-speed impact designed to break the aircraft into multiple pieces and the extended landing gear designed to sink the plane as quickly as possible shows a 鈥渃lear intent to hide the evidence of the crash鈥.

Pilots don鈥檛 often lower the undercarriage if they need to perform an emergency landing on water. This points authorities into believing it wasn鈥檛 an emergency landing gone wrong.

MH370 Pilot Zaharie Ahmad Shah. Photo /  SuppliedMH370 Pilot Zaharie Ahmad Shah. Photo / Supplied

Why it crashed: Mass murder/suicide by pilot

The most high-profile theory is that 53-year-old pilot听Captain Zaharie Ahmad Shah deliberately crashed the plane.

Former Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott revealed the 鈥渉ighest levels鈥 of the Malaysian government believed from 鈥渧ery early on鈥 that the MH370 tragedy was a murder-suicide plot.

鈥淢y understanding 鈥 my very clear understanding 鈥 from the very top levels of the Malaysian government is that from very, very early on here they thought it was a murder-suicide by the pilot,鈥 Abbott told Sky 九一星空无限鈥櫶MH370: The Untold Story.

鈥淚鈥檓 not going to say who said what to whom. But let me reiterate, I want to be absolutely crystal clear, it was understood at the highest levels that this was almost certainly murder-suicide by the pilot.鈥

This was backed by a report in 2016 that claimed Shah had conducted an exercise on his home flight simulator less than a month before the ill-fated flight that closely matched the path MH37 would take through the Indian Ocean.

This theory was also the conclusion of the first independent study into the disaster by the New Zealand-based air accident investigator, Ewan Wilson.

听that friends of Shah also said he was 鈥渓onely and sad鈥 and suffering from depression in the lead-up to the flight.

He also had reportedly split from his wife Fizah Khan.

Zaharie Ahmad Shah, the pilot of missing Malaysian Airlines Boeing 777 flight MH370, appeared in a YouTube video in front of his home-built flight simulator. Zaharie Ahmad Shah, the pilot of missing Malaysian Airlines Boeing 777 flight MH370, appeared in a YouTube video in front of his home-built flight simulator.

Captain Shah was also enraged after his relative Anwar Ibrahim, Malaysia鈥檚 opposition leader at the time of the crash in 2014, was convicted of sodomy the day before MH370 disappeared.

Shah was reportedly an avid supporter of Ibrahim, and the pilot鈥檚 Facebook account was also labelled a 鈥渢reasure trove鈥 of political activity and anti-government sentiment.

Leading aviation safety investigator and retired pilot John Cox also said the demise of MH370 was no accident.

Author and journalist Ean Higgins agreed, stating Shah had enough motivation if he wanted to take 鈥渄rastic action鈥.

So how did Shah allegedly carry out the alleged mass murder?

A working theory is that he locked his co-pilot out of the cockpit, closed down all communications, depressurised the main cabin, causing passengers on board to die from a lack of oxygen, and disabled the aircraft so it would continue flying until it ran out of petrol.

Catastrophic systems failure caused the plane to crash land in the ocean

One theory is that a catastrophic event such as a fire disabling much of the equipment on board resulted in the pilots turning the plane back towards the Malaysian peninsula in the hope of landing at the nearest airport.

The plane did make a sudden U-turn, a manoeuvre the pilot would not normally make on a routine flight unless confronted with a sudden and desperate emergency.

A fire in a similar aircraft parked at Cairo Airport in 2011 was caused by an issue with the first officer鈥檚 oxygen mask tubing.

Law firm Stewarts Law, which has litigated in a series of air disasters, believes the plane crashed after a fire - similar to the blaze on the Cairo airport runway - broke out in the cockpit.

Missing Malaysia Airlines pilots Fariq Ab Hamid (left) and Zaharie Ahmad Shah.Missing Malaysia Airlines pilots Fariq Ab Hamid (left) and Zaharie Ahmad Shah.

MH370 was hijacked

One theory is that another pilot or passenger hijacked the plane with the intention of landing it before escaping.

However, the belief is that the plan failed and they suffered hypoxia following decompression and died along with the rest of the people on board.

Unofficial researchers identified more than 600 possible runways at which the plane was capable of landing.

The plane鈥檚 co-pilot was First Officer Fariq Abdul Hamid, who, at 27, was relatively inexperienced, and MH370 was his final training flight.

However, it is not believed he had any motive to down the plane.

Uncontrolled decompression caused all on board to pass out before crash

The Australian Transport Safety Bureau (ATSB) said an unresponsive crew or hypoxia event was more likely than an in-flight upset (for example, a stall) or a glide event such as engine failure of fuel exhaustion.

At the time they said an uncontrolled drop in cabin pressure from human error or structural failure could have led to the crew becoming unresponsive, or even dying from hypoxia.

They indicated this theory 鈥渂est fits鈥 the evidence for the five-hour period in which the plane flew over the Indian Ocean without any communication or wild deviation.

Despite this, experts have not been able to come to a consensus on this theory.

The shooting down of MH17 hit Malaysia Airlines hard not long after MH370's disappearance. Photo  / APThe shooting down of MH17 hit Malaysia Airlines hard not long after MH370's disappearance. Photo / AP

MH370 was shot down

The theory that MH370 was shot down originated from American political commentator Rush Limbaugh, according to CNN.

Others threw weight behind the claim, citing previous events where civilian aircraft had been shot down by military forces.

Iran Air Flight 655 was shot down by the United States in 1988, and KAL 007 by the Soviet Union in 1983.

However, there is no evidence MH370 was shot down.

A Malaysian defence official, Ackbal bin Haji Abdul Samad, said it was 鈥渉ighly not possible鈥 that his country鈥檚 air force had shot down the plane.

On December 22, 2014 the former head of Proteus Airlines, Marc Dugain, claimed the plane may have been shot down by US military personnel out of fear of an attack similar to the September 11 attacks on their Navy Base in Diego Garcia.

Other wild MH370 theories

Some other theories include North Korea hijacking the plane and taking it back to the hermit nation because Kim Jong-un wanted it for experimentation, while others speculated a newBermuda Triangle in Vietnamese waters is to blame.

Desperate family members of missing passengers also reported being able to ring the mobile phones of their loved ones days after the plane had disappeared.

It led to speculation they were still alive somewhere.

It was claimed that some were able to find their relatives on a Chinese instant messenger service, suggesting their phones were still online.

So-called phantom calls led many to assume the flight had not crashed.

However, it was debunked by tech experts who explained that phones that had been switched off don鈥檛 always go straight to voicemail, saying it changed depending on the network and location.

The believed resting place of missing flight MH370, according to British aerospace engineer Richard Godfrey. Photo / SuppliedThe believed resting place of missing flight MH370, according to British aerospace engineer Richard Godfrey. Photo / Supplied

10 years on: What is next in the hunt for MH370?

As the 10th anniversary of the disappearance of MH370 passes, authorities have said they鈥檙e open to听resuming a search for the missing plane.

The Malaysian Government revealed they have recently been approached by US-based marine robotics company Ocean Infinity, who have made a 鈥渃redible鈥 search proposal.

Malaysian transport minister Anthony Loke revealed the proposal involves a no-fine, no-fee offer, meaning it won鈥檛 cost Malaysia a cent if nothing is found.

鈥淢eaningful changes have been made to prevent a repeat of this tragedy, but I am also clearly aware that the task remains incomplete,鈥 Loke said, adding that officials will 鈥渄o everything possible to solve this mystery once and for all鈥.

鈥淭he Ministry of Transport are ready to invite Ocean Infinity to Malaysia to discuss the proposal of a no-fine, no-fee proposal,鈥 Loke continued. 鈥淲e are waiting for Ocean Infinity to provide the suitable dates, and I will meet them any time that they are ready to come to Malaysia.鈥

Ocean Infinity didn鈥檛 reveal whether it has any new information related to the decade-long mystery, but is prepared to take on the task.

鈥淔inding MH370 and bringing some resolution for all connected with the loss of the aircraft has been a constant in our minds since we left the southern Indian Ocean in 2018,鈥 CEO Oliver Plunkett said.

Wreckage has been found near Reunion Island, off the coast of Madagascar.Wreckage has been found near Reunion Island, off the coast of Madagascar.

鈥淪ince then, we have focused on driving the transformation of operations at sea; innovating with technology and robotics to further advance our ocean search capabilities.

鈥淭his search is arguably the most challenging, and indeed pertinent one out there. We鈥檝e been working with many experts, some outside of Ocean Infinity, to continue analysing the data in the hope of narrowing the search area down to one in which success becomes potentially achievable.鈥

Loke declined to reveal the fee proposed by Ocean Infinity if it finds the plane, as this is subject to negotiation. He said financial cost is not an issue and that he doesn鈥檛 foresee any hindrances for the search to proceed if all goes well.

A new search, with new advances in technology, could provide family members of those on board much-needed closure.

鈥淚鈥檓 on top of the world,鈥 Jacquita Gomes, whose flight attendant husband was on the plane, said about the announcement at the anniversary event, according to听.

鈥淲e have been on a roller coaster for the last 10 years. ... If it is not found, I hope that it will continue with another search.鈥

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you