九一星空无限

ZB ZB
Opinion
Live now
Start time
Playing for
End time
Listen live
Up next
ZB

'Morally and legally unacceptable': Farmers fined after cow skinned alive on livestream

Author
NZ Herald,
Publish Date
Thu, 27 Nov 2025, 2:41pm

'Morally and legally unacceptable': Farmers fined after cow skinned alive on livestream

Author
NZ Herald,
Publish Date
Thu, 27 Nov 2025, 2:41pm

Two Canterbury farmers have been convicted after a mother cow was skinned alive as the act was livestreamed to viewers on social media.

While the court acknowledged that it could not be proven whether the cow consciously experienced suffering, the video has left Argie Villa, 34, and Russel Galeos, 33, standing before a judge.

Appearing in Christchurch District Court on Monday, the pair were fined $2000 each on a charge under the Animal Welfare Act.

The court determined that the two farmers did not take adequate measures to minimise unnecessary or unreasonable pain and distress.

But Danette Wereta, General Secretary of the Animal Justice Party, said it was 鈥渦nthinkable to consider that [the cow] did not feel extreme pain or terror鈥.

鈥淩eferring to her as 鈥榠t鈥 also highlights the systemic problem; she was a living, sentient mum capable of fear and suffering,鈥 Wereta said.

鈥淚f a human had been treated in this way, the criminal liability would be indisputable.

鈥淵et under current law, the burden of proof falls on an animal that cannot speak for herself.

鈥淭his is morally and legally unacceptable.鈥

Wereta said while New Zealand is marketed as a 鈥渃lean, green country鈥 that there were many 鈥渄irty dairy and environmentally harmful farming practices鈥.

鈥淩ecent changes allowing mumma pigs to be kept in cages and the proposed rollback of live animal exports reveal what farming in New Zealand is really like - cruel, shocking, and unethical,鈥 Wereta said.

Wereta claimed this was 鈥渘ot an isolated incident鈥.

鈥淔ootage from farms around the country reveals systemic cruelty, fear, and neglect endured by farmed animals,鈥 Wereta said.

鈥淭he legal loopholes that allow such acts to go insufficiently punished must be closed and minimum standards raised in codes of welfare鈥.

The farmers pleaded guilty under the Animal Welfare Act and were each fined $2000.

Police were approached for a comment and referred enquiries to the Ministry for Primary Industries, which has also been contacted.

Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you